Generation PRX
Skin deep
(Originally Published in Kantipur national daily, 5 August and the conversion version is published in NEPALI TIMES)
As the Miss Nepal contest draws near, opposition to it has been raised once more. This isn't new. In 1994, Ruby Rana became the first Nepali to be crowned amidst unnecessary controversy, partly orchestrated by the media. But the Kathmandu Jaycees continues to organize the contest every year.
Every competition has its limitations and Miss Nepal is no exception. Some people just can't qualify. But for any college student, five feet and above there is no problem. Look at it this way: at least someone gets to show off her talent.
The argument that beauty contests must be banned because they take women into the world of glamor is an attack on individual freedom itself. That is an individual choice and it's none of our business. Why are the protestors mainly women? Could there be an element of the stereotyped 'jealous woman' at work here? A winner is honoured, not oppressed. A Miss Nepal has a choice to appear or not appear on television.
Then there is the objection to the bikini round while representing Nepal in the internationals, but to win a title it is necessary to play by the rules. It may not be acceptable in our culture but it is in theirs, and women from a multitude of cultures will be there.
We talk about modernisation, and hope to catch up with developed countries. Is it oppression when you participate in a contest out of your own free will, or when you rally against a changing society? Does it make any sense to burn tyres or take part in a contest that brings out your talents?
As the Miss Nepal contest draws near, opposition to it has been raised once more. This isn't new. In 1994, Ruby Rana became the first Nepali to be crowned amidst unnecessary controversy, partly orchestrated by the media. But the Kathmandu Jaycees continues to organize the contest every year.
Every competition has its limitations and Miss Nepal is no exception. Some people just can't qualify. But for any college student, five feet and above there is no problem. Look at it this way: at least someone gets to show off her talent.
The argument that beauty contests must be banned because they take women into the world of glamor is an attack on individual freedom itself. That is an individual choice and it's none of our business. Why are the protestors mainly women? Could there be an element of the stereotyped 'jealous woman' at work here? A winner is honoured, not oppressed. A Miss Nepal has a choice to appear or not appear on television.
Then there is the objection to the bikini round while representing Nepal in the internationals, but to win a title it is necessary to play by the rules. It may not be acceptable in our culture but it is in theirs, and women from a multitude of cultures will be there.
We talk about modernisation, and hope to catch up with developed countries. Is it oppression when you participate in a contest out of your own free will, or when you rally against a changing society? Does it make any sense to burn tyres or take part in a contest that brings out your talents?
Comment
-
Comment by Jones Franzel on February 23, 2009 at 3:42pm - A really interesting question, Aashis! It sounds like you would advocate for the contests as a way to show off talent - yes? Can you link to your radio show discussion?
-
Comment by Aashis Luitel on February 23, 2009 at 9:11am - this is wat a hot issue in my country Nepal.and i have done a discussion program in Radi show on it.
About
Who's in Generation PRX?
Meet the Generation PRX Network
YouthCast: GPRX's Podcast
Become a fan 
Now on YouthCast
My Socialism by Andy Boyd
My Socialism by Andy Boyd puts us in the passenger seat of Andy's car as he drives around Phoenix, AZ and gets angsty about its ecology and economy.© 2010 Created by Jones Franzel on Ning. Create a Ning Network!
You need to be a member of Generation PRX - Social Network for Youth Radio Producers to add comments!
Join this Ning Network